Log in to view more.

Connect API to view more.

Upgrade to Pro to see the full data

Have an account? Log in See Pro plans

US Sector Rotation Backtest: 34.1% Max Drawdown, 9.4% a Year vs 10.9% for SPY

TopStellar
Fri, 20 Nov 2026 04:45:25 GMT
SPY lost 37% in 2008. This strategy made 17% that year. Since 2019, though, it has trailed the index almost every year. US Sector Rotation moves between 9 US sector ETFs and holds the 3 with the strongest momentum each month. When SPY falls below its 200-day moving average, it sells the sectors and holds intermediate Treasuries (IEF) instead. Backtested from 2003 to 2026 at 0.1% per side for fees and slippage, its worst drawdown was 34.1%, against 55.2% for holding SPY. The price is return, which trails the index: 9.4% a year against 10.9% for SPY. What sector rotation does The US market splits into sectors such as energy, financials, technology, health care and utilities, and each has its own ETF. This strategy uses the 9 SPDR sector funds that launched in 1998 and still trade today, so the list carries no survivorship bias. At the start of each month it compares each sector's return from a year ago to a month ago, known as 12-1 momentum, and holds the top 3 in equal weight. The latest month is skipped because very short-term moves often reverse. A market filter sits on top. If SPY is below its 200-day average at the monthly check, everything moves into Treasuries. Over the backtest it held Treasuries about 17% of the time. It only buys, never shorts and never uses leverage. We scanned the lookback from 168 to 336 days and the skip from 0 to 42 days, and Sharpe stayed between 0.53 and 0.69. Every year of the backtest YearStrategySPY 2003 (from Aug)+15.6%+13.9% 2004+12.0%+10.7% 2005+18.4%+4.8% 2006+5.7%+15.8% 2007+15.5%+5.1% 2008+16.7%−36.8% 2009+14.0%+26.4% 2010+10.9%+15.1% 2011−2.4%+1.9% 2012+6.4%+16.0% 2013+38.0%+32.3% 2014+11.5%+13.5% 2015−6.0%+1.2% 2016+8.7%+12.0% 2017+12.8%+21.7% 2018−7.3%−4.6% 2019+7.8%+31.2% 2020−4.4%+18.3% 2021+18.7%+28.7% 2022−8.1%−18.2% 2023+10.1%+26.2% 2024+14.5%+24.9% 2025+8.1%+17.7% 2026 (to Nov 19)+12.5%+5.8% Backtest results do not promise future returns. Where it falls less In the 2008 crisis SPY fell 55% at worst. Over the same stretch the strategy fell no more than 9% and gained 16.7% for the year. The market filter moved it into Treasuries just as they rallied. In 2022 SPY dropped 24.5% at worst and the strategy 18.7%. Where it loses Its deepest drawdown was 34.1%, from October 2018 to March 2020. When the pandemic crash hit, SPY was still above its average at the start-of-month check. By the next check the fall was over, and it was slow to switch back afterwards too. Recent years have been hard. Since 2019, large tech stocks have led the US market. Holding only 3 sectors, it often missed tech or got pushed into Treasuries by a brief dip below the average. From 2019 to 2025 it trailed SPY every year except 2022, by about 23 points in both 2019 and 2020. Costs matter here. It changes holdings in nearly six months out of ten. At 0.1% per side, fees took about 16 percentage points over 23 years, roughly 0.7 points a year. Who it suits People who want to own US stocks but step aside in a long bear market like 2008. Expect to trail the index, possibly for several years in a row. If beating the index is the goal, holding SPY did better in the backtest. Running it yourself Add it to Blave Agent to rerun the backtest, change how many sectors it holds, or drop the market filter to see what it adds. Multi-asset US strategies cannot trade automatically yet, so for now it is a backtest. See US Sector Rotation in the strategy library →

Strategies like this can run on your Blave Agent.

Browse ready-made strategies with real backtests →